Discussion:
linux PAM and OpenPam diffs
R.Matl
2003-10-09 14:58:41 UTC
Permalink
Hi,

Can you tell me the differences between these two beasts ? I'd like
to try OpenPAM on linux as linux PAM seems a bit chaotic to me .

Thank you,
R.Matl
Joe Lewis
2003-10-09 20:10:40 UTC
Permalink
The differences you will find are :

A) - modules
OpenPAM doesn't have the complete range of Linux-PAM modules

B) - specifications
OpenPAM meets the PAM specs and only the PAM specs
Linux-PAM contains many extensions in addition to the specs

C) - codewise
Both include structures for declaring the module to PAM apps.
The structures are different.

D) - linking
OpenPAM modules must be linked in a certain way, or they won't work
Linux-PAM modules are much more dynamic.

E) - support
OpenPAM has no mailing list, and one person working on the code.
Linux-PAM has a mailing list that one can ask for help on.

F) - Documentation
OpenPAM has man pages.
Linux-PAM has man pages. People have written tutorials, etc.

The E) and F) items were the biggest issues for me. I wanted to use
Linux-PAM on my BSD machine, which uses OpenPAM. Still, I've begun
porting the pam_mysql module for use in the OpenPAM because I fear that
I'd mess something up and lock the system. However, my afinity lies
with Linux-PAM.

Joe
Post by R.Matl
Hi,
Can you tell me the differences between these two beasts ? I'd like
to try OpenPAM on linux as linux PAM seems a bit chaotic to me .
Thank you,
R.Matl
_______________________________________________
Pam-list mailing list
https://www.redhat.com/mailman/listinfo/pam-list
Steve Langasek
2003-10-09 20:05:41 UTC
Permalink
Post by Joe Lewis
E) - support
OpenPAM has no mailing list, and one person working on the code.
Linux-PAM has a mailing list that one can ask for help on.
Which makes it "a mailing list and no people working on the code",
right? ;)

Cheers,
--
Steve Langasek
postmodern programmer
Joe Lewis
2003-10-09 20:33:34 UTC
Permalink
Exactly.... [ducking for cover].... :)
Post by Steve Langasek
Post by Joe Lewis
E) - support
OpenPAM has no mailing list, and one person working on the code.
Linux-PAM has a mailing list that one can ask for help on.
Which makes it "a mailing list and no people working on the code",
right? ;)
Cheers,
Loading...